Local News

Privy Council upholds constitutionality of 2011 SoE

17 November 2026
This content originally appeared on Trinidad Guardian.
Promote your business with NAN

Se­nior Re­porter

[email protected]

The coun­try’s high­est ap­pel­late court has ruled that a State of Emer­gency (SoE), de­clared by the for­mer Peo­ple’s Part­ner­ship ad­min­is­tra­tion led by Prime Min­is­ter Kam­la Per­sad-Bisses­sar in 2011, was not un­con­sti­tu­tion­al.

Five Law Lords of the Unit­ed King­dom-based Privy Coun­cil made the rul­ing yes­ter­day as they de­ter­mined a fi­nal ap­peal from now-As­sis­tant Com­mis­sion­er of Po­lice (ACP) Earl Elie and two men, Ash­meed Mo­hammed and Do­minic Piti­lal, who were de­tained over an al­leged plot to kill gov­ern­ment min­is­ters dur­ing the SoE but were re­leased at the end of it, with­out be­ing charged.

While the Board re­ject­ed the trio’s chal­lenge to the va­lid­i­ty of the 2011 SoE, it found that the lo­cal Court of Ap­peal was wrong to have over­ruled a High Court Judge, who or­dered $50,000 in com­pen­sa­tion for Elie and Piti­lal for be­ing de­nied ac­cess to their lawyers af­ter they were de­tained by the po­lice.

La­dy Vivien Rose and Lord Ray­mond Do­her­ty, who wrote the Board’s de­ci­sion, found that a High Court Judge and the Court of Ap­peal were cor­rect to have re­ject­ed the trio’s case over the va­lid­i­ty and con­sti­tu­tion­al­i­ty of the SoE.

They found that the lo­cal courts ap­plied the cor­rect test in de­ter­min­ing whether the cir­cum­stances at the time jus­ti­fied the procla­ma­tion of the SoE by the then-Pres­i­dent on the ad­vice of the then-Gov­ern­ment.

Re­fer­ring to re­cent in­ter­na­tion­al judg­ments speak­ing against us­ing an SoE as an in­def­i­nite an­ti-crime ini­tia­tive, the Board not­ed that Sec­tion 8(2)(c) of the Con­sti­tu­tion per­mits such ex­treme ac­tion in lim­it­ed cir­cum­stances where there is a sud­den sit­u­a­tion in which the lives of many cit­i­zens are en­dan­gered.

It stat­ed that such sit­u­a­tions can oc­cur in a num­ber of ways in­clud­ing crim­i­nal ac­tiv­i­ty of such a na­ture and so ex­ten­sive that it en­dan­gers the lives of cit­i­zens or threat­ens the abil­i­ty of the gov­ern­ment to pro­vide for the safe­ty of its cit­i­zens.

It not­ed that the cas­es high­light­ed the need for courts to be vig­i­lant against at­tempts by gov­ern­ments to ad­dress prob­lems aris­ing from in­ad­e­quate re­sourc­ing and lax en­force­ment of or­di­nary crim­i­nal laws by con­fer­ring ex­or­bi­tant pow­ers on the po­lice and se­cu­ri­ty forces.

How­ev­er, the Board found that the 2011 SoE was jus­ti­fied based on the State’s ex­pla­na­tion that it was de­clared to ad­dress an ex­pect­ed surge in gang vi­o­lence fol­low­ing the ma­jor drug seizures at the time and a plot to as­sas­si­nate key gov­ern­ment of­fi­cials in­clud­ing Per­sad-Bisses­sar.

“The Board is al­so keen­ly aware of the fact that the judges in the courts be­low who unan­i­mous­ly up­held the va­lid­i­ty of the 2011 Procla­ma­tion them­selves lived through the days lead­ing up to the Procla­ma­tion and ex­pe­ri­enced the hor­ror and fear that must have af­fect­ed every­one liv­ing in T&T as de­scribed in the ev­i­dence,” the Board said.

“Al­though the de­ter­mi­na­tion of the va­lid­i­ty of the Procla­ma­tion is ul­ti­mate­ly a mat­ter for the Board’s as­sess­ment, the Board will be slow to ar­rive at a dif­fer­ent view from that of the lo­cal court that has ap­plied the cor­rect test and set out so ful­ly its as­sess­ment of the ev­i­dence,” it added.

The Board not­ed that the case specif­i­cal­ly dealt with the 2011 SoE and not sub­se­quent SoEs that have been pro­claimed be­tween De­cem­ber 2024 and Sep­tem­ber this year.

“The Board’s de­ci­sion in the present ap­peal may well there­fore have im­por­tant im­pli­ca­tions for the more re­cent states of emer­gency de­clared by the Gov­ern­ment,” it said.

Deal­ing with as­so­ci­at­ed reg­u­la­tions which in­fringed on the fun­da­men­tal con­sti­tu­tion­al rights of cit­i­zens, the Board found no is­sue with the 2011 reg­u­la­tions copy­ing sim­i­lar pro­vi­sions that were im­ple­ment­ed dur­ing the SoE for the 1990 At­tempt­ed Coup.

“The Board does not find it sur­pris­ing, giv­en the ur­gency of the emer­gency, that the Gov­ern­ment and the Pres­i­dent should look to pre­vi­ous reg­u­la­tions for as­sis­tance rather than seek to rein­vent the wheel,” it said. It al­so found that the mea­sures were rea­son­ably jus­ti­fi­able in the cir­cum­stances.

“In the case of both pre­ven­ta­tive de­ten­tion and the sus­pen­sion of bail and habeas cor­pus, the de­mo­c­ra­t­ic cre­den­tials of the mea­sures were strong. Great weight should be af­ford­ed to the judg­ment which was made as to where the pub­lic in­ter­est lay and where the bal­ance be­tween it and the rights of in­di­vid­u­als should be struck,” it said.

“If Par­lia­ment had con­cerns about the mea­sures, it could have raised them at any stage dur­ing the emer­gency (and in­deed it could have vot­ed to end the emer­gency),” it added.

In up­hold­ing the as­pect of Elie and Piti­lal’s case over ac­cess to an at­tor­ney of their choos­ing, the Board said, “The ap­pel­lants might well have great­ly ben­e­fit­ed from the ad­vice and sup­port of an at­tor­ney pre­pared to in­sist on greater de­tail be­ing pro­vid­ed to them of the al­le­ga­tions and the ba­sis for their de­ten­tion and to be able to li­aise with their fam­i­ly and friends in the out­side world to help es­tab­lish their in­no­cence.”

The trio was among a group of 17 men who were de­tained on pre­ven­tive de­ten­tion or­ders (PDOs) months af­ter the SoE was de­clared in Au­gust 2011.

They were all re­leased with­out be­ing charged af­ter the SoE end­ed in De­cem­ber that year.

Elie, who was a Sergeant when he was de­tained, re­ceived sev­er­al pro­mo­tions, the most re­cent of which came in De­cem­ber last year, when he was made an ACP and as­signed to the To­ba­go Di­vi­sion.

The trio, whose le­gal team was led by for­mer at­tor­ney gen­er­al Ramesh Lawrence Ma­haraj, SC, filed con­sti­tu­tion­al mo­tions chal­leng­ing the SoE procla­ma­tion and claim­ing that they had been wrong­ful­ly ar­rest­ed and de­tained.

The High Court Judge as­signed to pre­side over the three cas­es dis­missed their chal­lenge to the procla­ma­tion and the reg­u­la­tions but up­held an as­pect of Elie’s case, al­leg­ing that the of­fi­cer who ar­rest­ed him did not have the req­ui­site sus­pi­cion un­der the reg­u­la­tions to do so.

Elie was award­ed $100,000 in com­pen­sa­tion for the sev­en-day pe­ri­od he was de­tained be­fore he was placed on the PDO.

The judge al­so found that Elie and Piti­lal had been de­nied ac­cess to their lawyers in breach of their con­sti­tu­tion­al right and award­ed each of them $50,000 in com­pen­sa­tion.

In Jan­u­ary 2024, the Court of Ap­peal, led by then-Ap­pel­late Judge Al­lan Men­don­ca, up­held the judge’s find­ing in re­la­tion to the procla­ma­tion and reg­u­la­tions.

De­spite his find­ings on the is­sue, Jus­tice Men­don­ca al­so found that Piti­lal had been wrong­ful­ly ar­rest­ed like Elie and award­ed him the same $100,000 in com­pen­sa­tion.

He al­so found that the judge was wrong to have up­held Elie and Piti­lal’s claim over ac­cess to their lawyers, as he stat­ed that they were not ad­verse­ly af­fect­ed by their ab­sence, as they were not even­tu­al­ly charged with any crim­i­nal of­fence.

The trio’s fi­nal ap­peal on­ly chal­lenged the Ap­peal Court’s find­ing on their ac­cess to their lawyers and over the va­lid­i­ty of the SoE.

The trio was al­so rep­re­sent­ed by Robert Strang, while the Of­fice of the At­tor­ney Gen­er­al was rep­re­sent­ed by King’s Coun­sel Pe­ter Knox.