Senior Reporter
The country’s highest appellate court has ruled that a State of Emergency (SoE), declared by the former People’s Partnership administration led by Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar in 2011, was not unconstitutional.
Five Law Lords of the United Kingdom-based Privy Council made the ruling yesterday as they determined a final appeal from now-Assistant Commissioner of Police (ACP) Earl Elie and two men, Ashmeed Mohammed and Dominic Pitilal, who were detained over an alleged plot to kill government ministers during the SoE but were released at the end of it, without being charged.
While the Board rejected the trio’s challenge to the validity of the 2011 SoE, it found that the local Court of Appeal was wrong to have overruled a High Court Judge, who ordered $50,000 in compensation for Elie and Pitilal for being denied access to their lawyers after they were detained by the police.
Lady Vivien Rose and Lord Raymond Doherty, who wrote the Board’s decision, found that a High Court Judge and the Court of Appeal were correct to have rejected the trio’s case over the validity and constitutionality of the SoE.
They found that the local courts applied the correct test in determining whether the circumstances at the time justified the proclamation of the SoE by the then-President on the advice of the then-Government.
Referring to recent international judgments speaking against using an SoE as an indefinite anti-crime initiative, the Board noted that Section 8(2)(c) of the Constitution permits such extreme action in limited circumstances where there is a sudden situation in which the lives of many citizens are endangered.
It stated that such situations can occur in a number of ways including criminal activity of such a nature and so extensive that it endangers the lives of citizens or threatens the ability of the government to provide for the safety of its citizens.
It noted that the cases highlighted the need for courts to be vigilant against attempts by governments to address problems arising from inadequate resourcing and lax enforcement of ordinary criminal laws by conferring exorbitant powers on the police and security forces.
However, the Board found that the 2011 SoE was justified based on the State’s explanation that it was declared to address an expected surge in gang violence following the major drug seizures at the time and a plot to assassinate key government officials including Persad-Bissessar.
“The Board is also keenly aware of the fact that the judges in the courts below who unanimously upheld the validity of the 2011 Proclamation themselves lived through the days leading up to the Proclamation and experienced the horror and fear that must have affected everyone living in T&T as described in the evidence,” the Board said.
“Although the determination of the validity of the Proclamation is ultimately a matter for the Board’s assessment, the Board will be slow to arrive at a different view from that of the local court that has applied the correct test and set out so fully its assessment of the evidence,” it added.
The Board noted that the case specifically dealt with the 2011 SoE and not subsequent SoEs that have been proclaimed between December 2024 and September this year.
“The Board’s decision in the present appeal may well therefore have important implications for the more recent states of emergency declared by the Government,” it said.
Dealing with associated regulations which infringed on the fundamental constitutional rights of citizens, the Board found no issue with the 2011 regulations copying similar provisions that were implemented during the SoE for the 1990 Attempted Coup.
“The Board does not find it surprising, given the urgency of the emergency, that the Government and the President should look to previous regulations for assistance rather than seek to reinvent the wheel,” it said. It also found that the measures were reasonably justifiable in the circumstances.
“In the case of both preventative detention and the suspension of bail and habeas corpus, the democratic credentials of the measures were strong. Great weight should be afforded to the judgment which was made as to where the public interest lay and where the balance between it and the rights of individuals should be struck,” it said.
“If Parliament had concerns about the measures, it could have raised them at any stage during the emergency (and indeed it could have voted to end the emergency),” it added.
In upholding the aspect of Elie and Pitilal’s case over access to an attorney of their choosing, the Board said, “The appellants might well have greatly benefited from the advice and support of an attorney prepared to insist on greater detail being provided to them of the allegations and the basis for their detention and to be able to liaise with their family and friends in the outside world to help establish their innocence.”
The trio was among a group of 17 men who were detained on preventive detention orders (PDOs) months after the SoE was declared in August 2011.
They were all released without being charged after the SoE ended in December that year.
Elie, who was a Sergeant when he was detained, received several promotions, the most recent of which came in December last year, when he was made an ACP and assigned to the Tobago Division.
The trio, whose legal team was led by former attorney general Ramesh Lawrence Maharaj, SC, filed constitutional motions challenging the SoE proclamation and claiming that they had been wrongfully arrested and detained.
The High Court Judge assigned to preside over the three cases dismissed their challenge to the proclamation and the regulations but upheld an aspect of Elie’s case, alleging that the officer who arrested him did not have the requisite suspicion under the regulations to do so.
Elie was awarded $100,000 in compensation for the seven-day period he was detained before he was placed on the PDO.
The judge also found that Elie and Pitilal had been denied access to their lawyers in breach of their constitutional right and awarded each of them $50,000 in compensation.
In January 2024, the Court of Appeal, led by then-Appellate Judge Allan Mendonca, upheld the judge’s finding in relation to the proclamation and regulations.
Despite his findings on the issue, Justice Mendonca also found that Pitilal had been wrongfully arrested like Elie and awarded him the same $100,000 in compensation.
He also found that the judge was wrong to have upheld Elie and Pitilal’s claim over access to their lawyers, as he stated that they were not adversely affected by their absence, as they were not eventually charged with any criminal offence.
The trio’s final appeal only challenged the Appeal Court’s finding on their access to their lawyers and over the validity of the SoE.
The trio was also represented by Robert Strang, while the Office of the Attorney General was represented by King’s Counsel Peter Knox.
Related News
Al-Rawi: Death threats for teen, family involved in fatal boating collision
Democrats usher in new era with resounding win over Trump’s Republicans
U.S. escalates economic campaign against Cuba and targets China-based suppliers