Senior Reporter
kay-marie.fletch[email protected]
Two senior attorneys are defending more than $3 million in legal fees claimed by attorneys representing the State in the controversial Hadeed State of Emergency detention case, rejecting Opposition MP Stuart Young’s criticism that the charges are obscene.
Speaking to Guardian Media yesterday, Criminal Bar Association president Israel Khan, SC, defended the fees, arguing that the complexity and urgency of the proceedings must be considered when assessing the amounts charged, regardless of whether the attorneys hold the designation of senior counsel.
“Good lawyers are not cheap and cheap lawyers are not good… I find the fees are very reasonable in relation to the complexity of the matter and the urgency of the matter. I find it is reasonable,” Khan said.
His comments follow Young’s criticism of $3,034,375 in legal fees claimed by attorneys Gerald Ramdeen and Dayadai Harripaul for representing the State in court proceedings arising from the arrest and detention of businessman Dominic Hadeed and his wife Genevieve.
The couple was arrested in June over their suspected involvement in an alleged plot to assassinate Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar and other senior Government officials. They spent nearly a month in detention under emergency powers before being released without criminal charges.
However, their legal challenge resulted in proceedings in the High Court and Court of Appeal, with the State retaining local attorneys and two British King’s Counsel to defend its actions.
A written parliamentary response from Attorney General John Jeremie revealed that Ramdeen claimed $984,375 for the High Court proceedings and $1.25 million for the Court of Appeal, bringing his total to $2,234,375.
Harripaul claimed $450,000 for the High Court and $350,000 for the Court of Appeal, totalling $800,000.
The $3 million figure does not include fees for the two British King’s Counsel, Sir James Raymond Eadie and Richard John Thomas, who were also retained by the State.
In a Facebook post on Sunday, Young described the fees as “obscene and abusive,” questioning whether taxpayers should be made to foot the bill, particularly since neither Ramdeen nor Harripaul holds the designation of Senior Counsel.
However, Khan yesterday rejected Young’s criticism, arguing that the attorneys’ professional designations should not be the sole consideration when assessing their charges.
He explained that the complexity of the case, the urgency of the work and the time spent preparing legal arguments must also be considered.
He also noted that the Legal Profession Act provides guidelines governing the fees attorneys may charge.
Questioned about the additional costs associated with retaining the two British King’s Counsel, Khan acknowledged that the final legal bill could be considerably higher.
However, he said he could not determine whether those fees were justified without knowing the amounts charged and the legal work undertaken.
Khan explained that the British attorneys would charge according to rates applicable in the United Kingdom.
“They will charge fees in relation to what they will charge in the United Kingdom. And not only that, the remote costs, see what about the hotel bills and the meals and travelling and all that for England to come in. So their fees will be separate and apart,” Khan said.
But Khan went further, accusing Young of using the controversy to score political points.
He said, “I think it’s just a distraction really, the criticism. I think he has taken every opportunity to prove to the PNM supporters that he’s the de facto leader of the party.”
Khan also questioned Young’s criticism of the current expenditure, pointing to legal fees paid to attorneys retained under the former PNM administration.
Former Legal Affairs minister Prakash Ramadhar also said he did not consider the $3 million in legal fees too high.
Speaking to Guardian Media via telephone yesterday, Ramadhar pointed to the cost of professional services, and suggested that Young’s criticisms were influenced by his position in Opposition.
“I don’t think that it’s too high… He’s in Opposition so he will say anything obnoxious and untrue,” Ramadhar said.
However, when asked whether the Government should publicly account for the fees, including those of the two British King’s Counsel, Ramadhar declined to comment further.
Related News
CAUGHT IN CROSSFIRE
Midterm elections are coming to a close as voters pass judgment on Trump’s second term
After midterm loss, Trump is left to weigh his next move in Iran war that contributed to G...