Derek Achong
Senior Reporter
A police officer has obtained an injunction blocking the Trinidad and Tobago Police Service (TTPS) from forcing him to shave his beard pending the determination of his lawsuit challenging a policy barring officers from having beards unless they can raise religious and medical grounds.
High Court Judge Nadia Kangaloo recently granted the interim injunction for Cailon Daniel as his lawsuit was assigned to her.
In his court filings, obtained by Guardian Media, Daniel’s lawyers led by Senior Counsel Anand Ramlogan of Freedom Law Chambers, noted that in January the Court of Appeal upheld a legal challenge from Kristian Khan, a Muslim officer, over the constitutionality of the policy.
“The present claim is materially broader: it does not depend upon the Claimant’s race or religion, but challenges the rationality, justification and proportionality of the clean-shaven policy itself,” they said.
They noted that the Appeal Court’s ruling in the other officer’s case was instructive in the wider challenge now being raised by Daniel.
“It (the court) held that there was no identifiable or reasonably justifiable public interest in the facial-hair restriction, that a beard did not interfere with a police officer’s powers of criminal investigation or arrest, that there was no sufficient connection between the asserted public interest and the prohibition, and that the proportionality test was not satisfied,” they said.
As a secondary ground, Daniel’s lawyers are contending that the policy is inherently discriminatory to officers such as him, who suffer from pseudofolliculitis barbae- a dermatological condition aggravated by close shaving.
“It (the condition) disproportionately, although not exclusively, affects men of African and mixed racial origin, who are compelled either to shave to their medical detriment or repeatedly seek exemptions from a rule which others can obey without comparable injury,” they said.
They claimed that the policy does not pursue legitimate aims capable of interfering with officers’ constitutional rights.
“A police officer’s ability to perform the statutory duties of policing, and to project a neat and professional image, does not depend upon whether he is clean-shaven. A short, well-groomed beard is entirely compatible with professional policing,” they said.
Daniel claimed that he decided to pursue the case in August after a Corporal questioned how he was allowed to keep a beard while assigned to the Police Administration Building in Port-of-Spain, despite not being a Muslim.
He claimed that his colleague was not aware that he had received a medical exemption.
Daniel’s lawyers acknowledged that after Khan’s legal victory, the TTPS amended the policy to provide exemptions based on religious grounds.
They also pointed out that several prison officers successfully pursued lawsuits over a similar policy in the T&T Prison Service.
Through the lawsuit, Daniel is seeking a series of declarations against the policy as well as compensation for breaches of his constitutional rights.
Daniel is also being represented by Renuka Rambhajan, Ganesh Saroop, Vishaal Siewsaran and Maureen Radhay.