Derek Achong
The Privy Council has ruled that the 2011 State of Emergency (SoE), declared by the former People’s Partnership government, was constitutional and lawful, dismissing an appeal challenging its legality.
Delivering the judgment in London, Lady Vivien Rose said the measures were justified by the circumstances at the time.
“The measures were clearly needed to address the outbreak of widespread public violence,” she said.
The appeal was brought by now Assistant Commissioner of Police Earle Elie, Ashmeed Mohammed and Dominic Pitilal, who were detained during the SoE over an alleged plot to kill government ministers. They were released when the emergency ended without being charged.
The Board upheld the findings of the High Court and Court of Appeal on the constitutionality of the SoE and its associated regulations.
The ruling affirms the ability of the current and future governments to invoke a State of Emergency in similar circumstances, provided the constitutional requirements are satisfied.
However, it allowed part of the appeal concerning the denial of access to lawyers following the arrests of Elie and Pitilal.
The Privy Council reinstated the $50,000 in damages awarded by the High Court for breaching their constitutional right to access legal representation of their choice.
Related News
Maloney residents call for more patrols but softer touch
Presto takes hydroponics programme to Marabella Primary
King’s slavery remarks spark renewed calls for apology, reparations